The products you buy through our links may earn us income commission. Oh, and if something isn’t in stock, sorry, it was at the time of posting (and all prices were accurate).
2026 was the year I relied on Etsy more than ever. Not only did I (literally) meet the best artisans and vendors, but I was also able to purchase custom designer pieces without spending a ton. In honor of my deep obsession, I’m throwing in a few of my favorites, along with a few editor-approved picks.
The unexpected accessory you’ll see everywhere this year…
I have Colman Domingo to thank for my obsession with brooches, so I dived in for my bride’s wedding look. These birthday flowers from Etsy are equal parts cute and stunning, and they add a little elegance to blazers, sweaters, and coats.
A cake that will become a family heirloom…
Because who doesn’t want to be a silly cow cake? This candle holder is made of ceramic and can hold one candle. It would make a very sweet gift for someone celebrating their first birthday, or an adult who knows how to have a good time.
A hat dedicated to the biggest fan of pesto…
Yes, you read that right. This hat is perfect for all foodies and pasta lovers. Our business director (a fellow Italian) bought it for himself after dropping it in his group chat, where the immediate and unanimous response was that he should buy it immediately. He did.
The best way to never lose your keys…
I may be one of the only people who thinks this, but my issue with Jellycat chains is that they are too big and bulky to actually fit on my keys. These key felt food chains are just the right size. They’re big enough to help you find your keys in a pinch, but they’re not too big to fit in your purse.
A big ring to add to the stack…
Meet the ring that calls it like it is. It’s simple, made with durable materials, and acts as a great conversation starter. I love that it blends in seamlessly with the rest of my rings, but makes enough of a statement to wear on its own. Get a silver for your best friend and a gold for yourself.
Custom return address label…
I’m getting married in October, so I’m in the season of writing tons of thank yous. I recently purchased this heart-shaped return address stamp, and while it may not seem necessary, it saved a lot of time writing my address on the back of envelopes. Not to mention, I love that it adds a personal touch.
The best way to make them…
Just choose their favorite songs (you must send them as an MP3 file) and the store will burn them to vinyl. I love that you can even customize the sleeve with a photo or personal message. If your present has almost everything, definitely go for this.
The perfect gift for the guy in your life…
During my wedding, I thought a lot about fun gifts for the guys. I recently came across these simple bobo glass boxes for groomsmen. They are thoughtful, funny and practical. I love giving people gifts they will actually use.
The downloadable templates I used for my bridal boxes…
I downloaded this template, edited it a bit and used it to make stickers for the front of my bridal boxes. They turned out great and it was an easy way to create a simple and tall white box.
An unusual notepad that helps solve tasks…
Sometimes simpler is better. This personalized planner has spaces for priorities, extensive to-do lists, tasks for the next day, and things you don’t want to forget. Customize it by adding your name. It’s slim enough to fit in a bag, but I buy two – one to keep at home and one for the office.
Genuine leather cover…
Designer handbag trends come and go all the time, so my biggest recommendation is to check out the handbag deals on Etsy. You can find many trendy silhouettes with high-quality materials at affordable prices. It is a small leather bag with wide straps.
An incense holder that doubles as a decorative…
I can always get behind a decorative piece that is practical. This lily-shaped incense holder will make a statement on any coffee table, and since it’s handmade, not every one will be exactly the same. Our senior editor is in white, but check out the red and lavender versions for a pop of color.
The Mushroom Disco Ball We Didn’t Know We Needed…
A disco mushroom? Say less. This is another statement piece that will help bring light into your space. Choose from five different sizes that include three color options. And no, you don’t have to wait for a party to stick it out.
Resin necklace from women’s brand…
I have said in the past my love for the woman-owned jewelry brand ActiveArtistry and its now sold-out initial bubble necklace. Lately I’ve been eyeing this resin heart necklace from the brand. Although it is minimal and simple, it is an easy way add color to the dress.
An easy birthday gift that looks expensive…
TaylorElliotDesigns is one of my favorite Etsy shops. She has many acrylic gifts that are inexpensive and still feel unique. I am pairing this confetti letter charm with a gift card for a friend.
A personalized book stamp for the avid collector…
If you are particularly proud of your book collection, you will appreciate this stamp. You can personalize with your name and a private phrase, such as “From the Library of”. It also ensures that your books are returned to their rightful owner after being loaned out.
A discrete ring that doubles as a fidget…
On stressful days, I reach for this sleek tri-color ring that doubles as a fidget toy. No one will ever know. Just cover it with your regular stack and you can spin different pieces when the urge strikes. It is made of sterling silver and sizes start at 5.
Chinoiserie candlesticks to host nights in…
If you’re itching to change up your decor but don’t have the budget, swapping in some fun candlesticks will do the trick. In Chinese design is timeless and will get you excited for spring. In addition, the wax is non-toxic.
A personalized accessory that makes a big difference…
Small but powerful, personalized luggage tags are useful because they help you quickly identify your suitcase in a sea of dark luggage. It’s made of durable saffiano PU leather and you can add your initials with gold foil.
A leather gift tag that gives them good points…
If their ideal Saturday is spent on the lawn and golfing in hand, this engraved leather tag will make a long me time. There are five design options (our favorite: the “best dad ever” with the name of the gift giver), plus it comes with a few trinkets inside. A small gift that feels personal, playful and completely at home.
Tomato candles heirloom shape..
I’ve never met a tomato candle I didn’t like. These are especially cute because they jazz up a boring scene in minutes. They are made of 100% soy wax and cotton wick for a clean burn, but we recommend leaving them on the table without lighting. Choose from two sizes and both red and green colors.
