Choosing a calorie tracker isn’t just a lifestyle choice—it’s a decision that directly affects the accuracy of your data, how well you’re sticking to your routine, and whether the program is on track with your health goals. In lose it vs mynetdiary Debates keep coming up, and for good reason: both programs are well-established, widely used, and really capable. But when you look at the numbers side by side, the differences are significant.
Database size and database quality
Lose it! more than 60 million food products, which is the largest database in the category. It’s impressive until you understand how it’s built: almost entirely through crowdsourcing. Users submit entries that come alive with minimal professional review. The result is duplicate records, calorie counts, and outdated information for revised products.
MyNetDiary takes the opposite approach. The 2M+ database is based on USDA and NCC research sources, verified daily by staff, and 2,500-3,500 new food offerings are reviewed by trained nutritionists before broadcast. Smaller, but effectively more reliable when accuracy is important.
Nutrient depth: Not even close
This is where it becomes difficult to ignore. MyNetDiary tracks 108 nutrients per food entry—including amino acids and omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acid subtypes—at every level, including the free version. Lose it! tracks only 4 nutrients in the free tier (core nutrition label values) and 27 in its paid premium plan.
For anyone managing a health condition, working with a nutritionist, or simply wanting a more complete picture of their nutrition, the difference is significant.
Free Tier: What you actually get without paying
MyNetDiary’s free tier includes barcode scanning, voice recording, full 108 nutrient tracking, custom macro goals, a shopping list, and zero ads, with no account or email address required. Lose it! puts barcode scanning, voice recording, and custom macro targeting behind a $79.99/year fee, and its free tier features ads. Some Premium customers have also reported seeing intrusive ads despite paying.
Recording speed is more important than you think
In a January 2026 iOS test that covered 127 food entries over a week, MyNetDiary required 711 actions to complete the entry. Lose it! 872 — 23% more effort was needed for the same results. Over months of daily use, this friction quietly kills durability.
User ratings tell the story
Analyzing 2,995 App Store reviews in April 2026, MyNetDiary averaged 4.54 out of 5. Lose it! average 3.46. Recent reviews of Lose It! frequent reference to UI changes that added additional registration steps and replaced the barcode scanner behind the payment wall.
Platforms like https://www.mynetdiary.com/ earn high satisfaction scores by solving the same problems that frustrate users of competing programs: slow registration, paid basics, and unreliable nutrition information.
Judgment
Lose it! if social challenges, group competitions and multilingual interface are your preferences. Choose MyNetDiary if you want verified data, deeper nutritional insight, faster logging, and a truly rewarding free experience without compromising on accuracy.
- About the Author
- Latest news
Our editorial team are writers and experts in their field. Their views and opinions are not necessarily those of Wellbeing Magazine. If you are under medical supervision, talk to your doctor or therapist before following the advice and recommendations in this article.
